Meet Our Team of Therapists

We understand the therapeutic relationship is central to healing. Our team of warm, skilled clinicians brings not just expertise but also authenticity, compassion, and heart to their work, helping you create positive change.

Finding the right therapist can be overwhelming
We're here to help you

Susan Goryeb Simms

Director – LCSW-R

A Message From Our Director

Welcome to Positive Therapy 4U, where compassion and evidence-based therapy meet. We’re so glad you’re here. Reaching out for support can feel vulnerable, and it also reflects courage and hope. I founded this practice with the intention of bringing together thoughtful, authentic therapists who are deeply committed to meaningful, client-centered work. My vision was to create a space where both clients and clinicians feel genuinely cared for—where compassion, respect, and integrity guide every interaction. We believe healing happens in safe, trusting relationships. Our work is trauma-informed, grounded, and collaborative, allowing you to explore life’s challenges openly and at your own pace. It is a true privilege to do this work, and we are honored to support you on your journey. [Read More]

Our Caring Therapists

  • Emily Evans

    Supervisor — LCSW, PMH-C

    I approach therapy with compassion, gentle guidance, and the belief that humor can be an important part of healing. My clinical focus is on anxiety and mood disorders during pregnancy, postpartum, and throughout motherhood. I am certified in perinatal mental health (PMH-C) through Postpartum Support International (PSI), an organization that provides education, resources, and community for mothers and professionals in—[Read More]

  • Alison Armbruster

    Therapist — MFA, LMSW

    In addition to being a Licensed Master Social Worker, I hold a Master of Fine Arts degree from New York University. I bring many years of experience working with children, teens, and adults, particularly within the world of the performing arts—an environment that has deeply shaped and inspired my therapeutic approach. My background as a performer and dance educator fostered—[Read More]

  • Stacy Ann Pennington Bartholomew

    Therapist — LMSW

    When we connect, we grow. I believe that supportive connection is the foundation for emotional healing and personal empowerment. In my therapy room, I strive to create a gentle, respectful, and collaborative space where warmth, honesty, and even a little humor help us move forward together. I work with children and adults who are seeking greater self-understanding, emotional regulation, and—[Read More]

  • Christina Erhardt

    Therapist — LMSW

    I’m most passionate about helping you put the pieces of yourself together in a way that leaves you hopeful, inspired and open to life’s possibilities. That starts with meeting you where you are to build a relationship of trust and care. As we work together, I promise you will get a sense of who I am as a person, because—[Read More]

  • Mary Ryan Garcia

    Therapist — MA, LMSW

    I believe that psychotherapy is a healing journey undertaken for personal discovery and growth. I meet clients where they are with a gentle, warm, and welcoming presence to find creative and practical ways to alleviate their emotional/psychological suffering and stress. As a graduate of Fordham University’s Graduate School of Social Service, my clinical emphasis is on assisting older adults from—[Read More]

  • Alexandria Gonzalez

    Therapist — LMSW, CASAC

    I’m a therapist who shows up collaboratively, with warmth, humor, and a direct, person-centered approach. I believe therapy works best when it feels like a real conversation; one where you feel supported, respected, and understood without judgment. While I specialize in trauma and substance use disorders, I also work with individuals navigating everyday stress, anxiety, relationship challenges, burnout, and the—[Read More]

  • Erin McKenna

    Therapist — LMSW

    I believe the most powerful tool in therapy is the strength of the relationships that we foster with each other. Using a mix of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Humanistic and Acceptance and Commitment-based approaches during the therapeutic process. During our time together, our goals are to gain insight and encourage increased understanding of the self and foster a safe environment for—[Read More]

  • Natalie Palermo

    Therapist — MHC-LP

    Hello, I’m Natalie, a compassionate and dedicated therapist with experience in helping individuals navigate life’s challenges. My approach to therapy is rooted in empathy and understanding, creating a safe space where you can explore your thoughts and feelings without judgment. I strive to create a space where clients feel seen, supported, and encouraged to grow at their own pace. My—[Read More]

  • Erika L Silverstein

    Therapist — LCSW

    For nearly three decades, I’ve had the privilege of walking alongside individuals and families during some of the most meaningful and transformative chapters of their lives. My work has spanned hospice, home care, bereavement support, and psychotherapy, giving me a deep appreciation for the quiet courage people carry through overwhelming moments. In the therapy room, I show up collaboratively and—[Read More]

  • Tabetha Swertfeger

    Therapist — MHC-LP

    I am a passionate MHC-LP who works with individuals, children, and teens. I recognize that therapy is not a one-size-fits-all process, and I strive to create a space where clients can feel seen, heard, and even share a laugh when things feel heavy. Life is messy, emotions are complicated, and sometimes a little humor is exactly what we need to—[Read More]

  • Jennifer Thieke

    Therapist — LCSW

    I love my work and find people endlessly fascinating. I’m deeply passionate about helping individuals better understand themselves and move toward becoming their most authentic selves, whatever that may look like for them. Many people come to therapy feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or disconnected, and I see the therapeutic space as an opportunity to make sense of difficult emotions and experiences—[Read More]

Start Your Healing Journey

Taking the first step toward therapy can feel uncertain, but it can also be the beginning of meaningful change. If you or a loved one is looking for supportive therapy in Port Jefferson, NY, or anywhere in New York via telehealth, we’re here to help.

Contact Positive Therapy 4U today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can support you.